FMIC + Battery question

Discussion of technical issues and ideas (engine, chassis)

Moderators: P3g4sus, Daniel, rat, Draco, Riekert

What do you think is the better option?

Smaller battery
2
25%
Relocate battery to boot
4
50%
I didn't have to move my battery ;)
2
25%
 
Total votes: 8

User avatar
Trance101
0.9 Bar Boost
Posts: 964
Joined: Tue Aug 14, 2007 1:54 pm
Car: S13
Engine: RB
Real Name: Ryan
Location: Durban

FMIC + Battery question

Post by Trance101 »

Hi guys,

I'm planning on getting myself a FMIC later this month and the kit I've been looking at will require me to move the battery. Now I know a lot of you guys have done a FMIC install so I was wondering what everyone did with their battery. Relocate to boot or get a smaller battery?

Does anyone know the round about price of those smaller batteries and do they give any problems?
RB25 S13 - in a perpetual state of broken-ness...
veecee
AGENT SX!
Posts: 7354
Joined: Wed Nov 08, 2006 3:49 pm

Post by veecee »

get a smaller battery and stick it in the boot!

poll closed! :wink:
ReeceZ wrote:I'm sorry... I couldn't help it. Please no one wish any hateful shit on me, I own an SX already
Ero_sennin
SX Forumholic
Posts: 1717
Joined: Tue Aug 01, 2006 4:00 pm
Car: S13
Engine: SR
Location: Will always be called Pretoria
Contact:

Post by Ero_sennin »

My FMIC did not come in kit form, was built for my car, so nothing had to be moved, dont think anything was cut either.

The only thing that bothers my about moving the battery to the boot is, wont the increased distance in cable add resistance or something, affecting the power going to the engine aswell as alternator to battery?
SONY Xplod inside
SR20DET Powered Red RS13
Image
User avatar
Trance101
0.9 Bar Boost
Posts: 964
Joined: Tue Aug 14, 2007 1:54 pm
Car: S13
Engine: RB
Real Name: Ryan
Location: Durban

Post by Trance101 »

Ero_sennin wrote:The only thing that bothers my about moving the battery to the boot is, wont the increased distance in cable add resistance or something, affecting the power going to the engine as well as alternator to battery?
Ya, that is what i am worried about. i don't know if it has any adverse effects.

I see on the nissansilvia.com forums a lot of people go with a smaller battery but then they also have problems coz of the smaller battery.

If relocating the battery doesn't really affect anything it may be the simplest (read cheapest ;)) option for me.
RB25 S13 - in a perpetual state of broken-ness...
Ero_sennin
SX Forumholic
Posts: 1717
Joined: Tue Aug 01, 2006 4:00 pm
Car: S13
Engine: SR
Location: Will always be called Pretoria
Contact:

Post by Ero_sennin »

yea if it doesn't affect anything really I would say move it then.
SONY Xplod inside
SR20DET Powered Red RS13
Image
User avatar
Doctor G
0.7 Bar Boost
Posts: 754
Joined: Tue May 22, 2007 6:48 am

Post by Doctor G »

I say move it to the boot. Make sure the cable you buy is thick enough. I think it's 12 gauge or something. Not sure.

If you do it properly it could even let your engine bay look cleaner.

ps: Any details on the kit you're buying? I've also been toying with the idea of a FMIC kit lately.
User avatar
Trance101
0.9 Bar Boost
Posts: 964
Joined: Tue Aug 14, 2007 1:54 pm
Car: S13
Engine: RB
Real Name: Ryan
Location: Durban

Post by Trance101 »

Doctor G wrote:I say move it to the boot. Make sure the cable you buy is thick enough. I think it's 12 gauge or something. Not sure.
Ya, it looks like my best bet is to move it. From what I've read the cable that should be used is 4 gauge (the lower the gauge the thicker the cable, kinda anti intuitive)
Doctor G wrote:ps: Any details on the kit you're buying? I've also been toying with the idea of a FMIC kit lately.
The one I've been looking at is an ebay kit. It should be suitable for my purposes and it seems not many people have had problems with it.

Here is the link: http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/89-94-ni ... enameZWDVW

The guy always has a few of these on sale and he's got good feedback. Its a 600x300x76 intercooler with 2.5" piping made to fit and all the clamps you need and stuff.

Cost is $199 and then shipping to SA is another $150. So it works out to be R2393.68 in total. Not to bad if you ask me.
RB25 S13 - in a perpetual state of broken-ness...
User avatar
Doctor G
0.7 Bar Boost
Posts: 754
Joined: Tue May 22, 2007 6:48 am

Post by Doctor G »

Cool. Just remember to add 20% import duty and 14% VAT on the price of the item you're buying.
Then add the shipping. Total price you would be looking at is around R2,860 to your local post office.

If you can, get the seller to email you the original invoice for $199 and then ask him to send a reduced invoice with the package. One for say $90. That way you only pay 20% import duties and VAT on the lower amount.
User avatar
Trance101
0.9 Bar Boost
Posts: 964
Joined: Tue Aug 14, 2007 1:54 pm
Car: S13
Engine: RB
Real Name: Ryan
Location: Durban

Post by Trance101 »

Doctor G wrote:Cool. Just remember to add 20% import duty and 14% VAT on the price of the item you're buying.
Then add the shipping. Total price you would be looking at is around R2,860 to your local post office.

If you can, get the seller to email you the original invoice for $199 and then ask him to send a reduced invoice with the package. One for say $90. That way you only pay 20% import duties and VAT on the lower amount.
Ya, import duties are a bugger. :( hadn't really thought about that until now. Thanks for the tip tho.

What do you guys think of the kit? Think its decent enough for a budget cooler?
RB25 S13 - in a perpetual state of broken-ness...
User avatar
Vlade
* - Club Pimp - *
Posts: 2776
Joined: Thu Oct 19, 2006 9:40 am
Car: Other
Real Name: Barend
Location: Auckland, New Zealand

Post by Vlade »

Yeah the most I've paid for duty+vat was 30% all together, but that was computer goods, on the car parts the most was 14%

I also ask all the importers to mark items as gifts, although this only works for < 4 packages per year.
Hairdresser MX5
User avatar
Phinx
0.7 Bar Boost
Posts: 720
Joined: Fri Oct 20, 2006 12:30 pm
Car: S13
Location: Pretoria

Post by Phinx »

Relocate the battery to the boot.
I have done it with no problem it really is a bit of work but not that
A.K.A - Wonderboy
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
1993 Nissan 200 SX
148 Kw - 250 NM @ 0.55 bar. 1.8T ATW
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
1989 Toyota Corrola
63kw - 117nm 1.3- N/A
18.2 @118,4 Km - Rainbow Raceway
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
User avatar
Speed breeder
0.7 Bar Boost
Posts: 741
Joined: Wed Jun 06, 2007 10:19 pm
Car: S13
Location: Roodepoort

Post by Speed breeder »

My battery has been relocated to the boot. 12 gauge cable sounds right (if memory serves).

I haven't experienced problems with charging or battery power/loss.

Startups are also not a problem.

My car is a weekend vehicle, so it only gets used every second weekend maybe, and the past 5 weeks it hasn't really moved, and it still starts every time first time.

I am sure that if you do the install properly and ensure you earth your cables properly you won't have hassles.
200sx CA18DET S13 - forged and flowed
veecee
AGENT SX!
Posts: 7354
Joined: Wed Nov 08, 2006 3:49 pm

Post by veecee »

12 gauge breeder??? sounds more like your shotgun ammo???

like trance said the lower the number the thicker the cable.

i have a battery that is half the size of the normal sx battery in my sx. havent had an issue for the last 3 years!!!

except that it really does move around quite a bit in that huge battery tray in the engine bay, especially when i'm on the track...

so i reckon the best would be a small little battery, relocated to the boot. no problems.

and if you were worried about the increase in resistance as the length of the cable increases, why dont you follow the flow of electrons from the battery to the alternator, to the supermulitplejunction, to the computer box, and then back to the engine. all in all, if you put all of the harnesses together, i guesstimate its probably about 10 or more meters long.

the increase in resistance should be negligable!
ReeceZ wrote:I'm sorry... I couldn't help it. Please no one wish any hateful shit on me, I own an SX already
User avatar
Trance101
0.9 Bar Boost
Posts: 964
Joined: Tue Aug 14, 2007 1:54 pm
Car: S13
Engine: RB
Real Name: Ryan
Location: Durban

Post by Trance101 »

Cool thx for the info guys. Sounds like relocating would be the cheapest option.
veecee wrote:i have a battery that is half the size of the normal sx battery in my sx. haven't had an issue for the last 3 years!!!
Do u know how much one of those would cost new? It would be the neater option IMO.
Vlade wrote:I also ask all the importers to mark items as gifts, although this only works for < 4 packages per year.
Well it the start of a new year so i should be good :P

I should be ordering my FMIC in 4 days time! Can't w8! :D
RB25 S13 - in a perpetual state of broken-ness...
User avatar
GoldenEagle
Slipping Clutch
Posts: 66
Joined: Wed Dec 12, 2007 6:06 am
Car: S13
Location: Dallas, Texas, USA
Contact:

Post by GoldenEagle »

I am using a smaller batter, despite not having a FMIC. For the time being I will wait to relocate my battery after I drop in an SR.

I am not sure what the equivalent of a Honda Civic or Mazda Miata is there in SA, but people here in the states typically go for one of those batteries. Others have used lawn mower batteries.
Post Reply