CA18DET rebuild opinions
Posted: Sun Dec 30, 2012 7:20 am
Hi Guys
So it turns out I do not in fat have a noisy lifter, after changing all 16 it seems the sound is still there. So it is either a piston slap or small end bearing, not sure which as it still bloody sounds like a lifter. But engine the engine must come out and be opened.
For you guys that don't know, it is running stock bottom end with bolt ons and was making 200RwKw with Meth and controlled by Wolf 3D ECU. Now since I am opening the motor I will be fitting Cometic head gasket, ARP studs and CP pistons. Bearings will obviously be replaced as well.
Now I have a 20 year plan for the SX, it need to be reliable as possible. My original goal for the car was to build the car Nissan should have, so it must have smooth power delivery and drive like any OEM car, huge strong boost is out of the question. Current TD04 turbo is probably almost maxing out at the current flow levels but that is fine because I have 1 Bar from 2800rpm (OEM like see...). No fancy fuels or octane boosters can be used.
Question is should I go 9:1 or 9.5:1 compression ratio, considering I won't be running over a bar?? Also while the motor is open should I go Forged rods as well? Or should I just fit new ARP rod bolts? I know at the power levels I will be running the stock rods will be more than ample but the motor must run for 20 years and head rood is a wonderful thing (read up, reliability). How effective is shot peening 20 year old rods, is it worth it? How much does it cost, considering ARP rod bolts are $60 and new rods are $360.
Just throw around your opinions guys and lets see if I can make my mind up.
PS: I love my car (no really I do, don't laugh) so reusing as many of my original parts is important to me. No SR20 swap ideas please DriftZ, if I wanted a tractor engine I would a Massey Fergusen ride on lawn mower.
Cheers Guys
Gary
So it turns out I do not in fat have a noisy lifter, after changing all 16 it seems the sound is still there. So it is either a piston slap or small end bearing, not sure which as it still bloody sounds like a lifter. But engine the engine must come out and be opened.
For you guys that don't know, it is running stock bottom end with bolt ons and was making 200RwKw with Meth and controlled by Wolf 3D ECU. Now since I am opening the motor I will be fitting Cometic head gasket, ARP studs and CP pistons. Bearings will obviously be replaced as well.
Now I have a 20 year plan for the SX, it need to be reliable as possible. My original goal for the car was to build the car Nissan should have, so it must have smooth power delivery and drive like any OEM car, huge strong boost is out of the question. Current TD04 turbo is probably almost maxing out at the current flow levels but that is fine because I have 1 Bar from 2800rpm (OEM like see...). No fancy fuels or octane boosters can be used.
Question is should I go 9:1 or 9.5:1 compression ratio, considering I won't be running over a bar?? Also while the motor is open should I go Forged rods as well? Or should I just fit new ARP rod bolts? I know at the power levels I will be running the stock rods will be more than ample but the motor must run for 20 years and head rood is a wonderful thing (read up, reliability). How effective is shot peening 20 year old rods, is it worth it? How much does it cost, considering ARP rod bolts are $60 and new rods are $360.
Just throw around your opinions guys and lets see if I can make my mind up.
PS: I love my car (no really I do, don't laugh) so reusing as many of my original parts is important to me. No SR20 swap ideas please DriftZ, if I wanted a tractor engine I would a Massey Fergusen ride on lawn mower.
Cheers Guys
Gary