Posted: Tue Aug 19, 2008 11:45 am
PFB makes some good points.
My feelings?
XMS, nice system, when it works...
Dick and go, they both are nice for race, just not enough resolution for street.
Problem with the dick and go is that they just dont have enough programable load & RPM points to really take advantage of mapping in a turbo motor especialy when it runs higher boost levels.
For a NA car they work mint, for a very low boost motor (.6 bar) they also still work semi ok, but as soon as you running decent boost like 1.5 bar it means that you can only map in 20% stages so like 1 in vacuum 1 @ 0 and and 3 in boost? i dont know about anyone else but the thought of programming at 1bar and then only again at 1.5bar is just stupid,
Think thats 25 programable points,,, near all decent managment systems use a 20X20 map = 400 points.
The key to making good reliable, usable and stable power along with fuel consumption when your not on the loud pedal is the ability to map it at all the desired points, good example is Myprodol's car, 11km/L at 130/140 and ran an 12.2 on break in boost... should get even lighter on fuel as everything finnishes seating.
Now, the next fun thing is finding a tuner that will actualy know to map it, let alone how to make it run perfectly at every point, bet you with the fuel prices these days though its worth spending the money doing it right the first time, probably save R150-R200 fuel per tank with a properly mapped ECU with a decent resolution.
For a race car when your turned off or all out the basic systems work well, for street, i would want as many load points as possible.
My feelings?
XMS, nice system, when it works...
Dick and go, they both are nice for race, just not enough resolution for street.
Problem with the dick and go is that they just dont have enough programable load & RPM points to really take advantage of mapping in a turbo motor especialy when it runs higher boost levels.
For a NA car they work mint, for a very low boost motor (.6 bar) they also still work semi ok, but as soon as you running decent boost like 1.5 bar it means that you can only map in 20% stages so like 1 in vacuum 1 @ 0 and and 3 in boost? i dont know about anyone else but the thought of programming at 1bar and then only again at 1.5bar is just stupid,
Think thats 25 programable points,,, near all decent managment systems use a 20X20 map = 400 points.
The key to making good reliable, usable and stable power along with fuel consumption when your not on the loud pedal is the ability to map it at all the desired points, good example is Myprodol's car, 11km/L at 130/140 and ran an 12.2 on break in boost... should get even lighter on fuel as everything finnishes seating.
Now, the next fun thing is finding a tuner that will actualy know to map it, let alone how to make it run perfectly at every point, bet you with the fuel prices these days though its worth spending the money doing it right the first time, probably save R150-R200 fuel per tank with a properly mapped ECU with a decent resolution.
For a race car when your turned off or all out the basic systems work well, for street, i would want as many load points as possible.